How to properly smuggle (with or even without TikZ)?












5















I am seeking to find something that allows me to "broadcast" macros outside a group. Concrete examples include paths and scopes in tizpictures. Here is an M(N)WE.



documentclass[tikz,border=3.14mm]{standalone}
usetikzlibrary{calc}
makeatletter
letsmuggleoutonepgfmath@smuggleone
makeatother
begin{document}
begin{tikzpicture}[globalize/.code n args={2}{xdef#2{#1}},
localize/.code n args={2}{pgfmathsetmacro{#2}{#1}typeout{#2}
%smuggleoutone#1
}]
begin{scope}[local bounding box=extra]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
pgfextra{xdefmyangle{n1}};
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (extra.north) {using verb|pgfextra|};
%
begin{scope}[local bounding box=globalize,xshift=3cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[globalize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (globalize.north) {using texttt{globalize}};
%
xdefmyangle{7}
begin{scope}[local bounding box=localize,xshift=6cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[localize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (localize.north) {attempt to smuggle};
%
end{tikzpicture}
end{document}


enter image description here



The two options on the left do partly what I am seeking to do, namely broadcast the macro myangle outside the path. However, they do it at the expense of making myangle global. TikZ has some internal commands that may allow one to avoid this, and to just smuggle the macro outside the path. Specifically, @DavidCarlisle suggested in the chat to use pgfmath@smuggleone. However, my above attempts failed, i.e. if I uncomment



%smuggleoutone#1


the code produces errors.



QUESTION: Can one smuggle the macro outside the group without making it global?



"BONUS": Of course it would be great if there was an explanation what all the smuggle commands do.



"BONUUUUS": Conceivably these methods may be useful independently of TikZ, so if there is a way not to make them depend on TikZ being loaded, this would be great, but is certainly not a requirement.










share|improve this question

























  • @Circumscribe Good idea, let's clean up. (I wait till I get a sign from David before I accept your nice answer.)

    – marmot
    1 hour ago











  • Of course, that's fair. He'll know a lot more about this than I do. And he'll probably have a nice solution that avoids all global assignments and instead implements a loop inserting however many aftergroups are necessary :D.

    – Circumscribe
    1 hour ago
















5















I am seeking to find something that allows me to "broadcast" macros outside a group. Concrete examples include paths and scopes in tizpictures. Here is an M(N)WE.



documentclass[tikz,border=3.14mm]{standalone}
usetikzlibrary{calc}
makeatletter
letsmuggleoutonepgfmath@smuggleone
makeatother
begin{document}
begin{tikzpicture}[globalize/.code n args={2}{xdef#2{#1}},
localize/.code n args={2}{pgfmathsetmacro{#2}{#1}typeout{#2}
%smuggleoutone#1
}]
begin{scope}[local bounding box=extra]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
pgfextra{xdefmyangle{n1}};
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (extra.north) {using verb|pgfextra|};
%
begin{scope}[local bounding box=globalize,xshift=3cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[globalize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (globalize.north) {using texttt{globalize}};
%
xdefmyangle{7}
begin{scope}[local bounding box=localize,xshift=6cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[localize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (localize.north) {attempt to smuggle};
%
end{tikzpicture}
end{document}


enter image description here



The two options on the left do partly what I am seeking to do, namely broadcast the macro myangle outside the path. However, they do it at the expense of making myangle global. TikZ has some internal commands that may allow one to avoid this, and to just smuggle the macro outside the path. Specifically, @DavidCarlisle suggested in the chat to use pgfmath@smuggleone. However, my above attempts failed, i.e. if I uncomment



%smuggleoutone#1


the code produces errors.



QUESTION: Can one smuggle the macro outside the group without making it global?



"BONUS": Of course it would be great if there was an explanation what all the smuggle commands do.



"BONUUUUS": Conceivably these methods may be useful independently of TikZ, so if there is a way not to make them depend on TikZ being loaded, this would be great, but is certainly not a requirement.










share|improve this question

























  • @Circumscribe Good idea, let's clean up. (I wait till I get a sign from David before I accept your nice answer.)

    – marmot
    1 hour ago











  • Of course, that's fair. He'll know a lot more about this than I do. And he'll probably have a nice solution that avoids all global assignments and instead implements a loop inserting however many aftergroups are necessary :D.

    – Circumscribe
    1 hour ago














5












5








5


1






I am seeking to find something that allows me to "broadcast" macros outside a group. Concrete examples include paths and scopes in tizpictures. Here is an M(N)WE.



documentclass[tikz,border=3.14mm]{standalone}
usetikzlibrary{calc}
makeatletter
letsmuggleoutonepgfmath@smuggleone
makeatother
begin{document}
begin{tikzpicture}[globalize/.code n args={2}{xdef#2{#1}},
localize/.code n args={2}{pgfmathsetmacro{#2}{#1}typeout{#2}
%smuggleoutone#1
}]
begin{scope}[local bounding box=extra]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
pgfextra{xdefmyangle{n1}};
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (extra.north) {using verb|pgfextra|};
%
begin{scope}[local bounding box=globalize,xshift=3cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[globalize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (globalize.north) {using texttt{globalize}};
%
xdefmyangle{7}
begin{scope}[local bounding box=localize,xshift=6cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[localize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (localize.north) {attempt to smuggle};
%
end{tikzpicture}
end{document}


enter image description here



The two options on the left do partly what I am seeking to do, namely broadcast the macro myangle outside the path. However, they do it at the expense of making myangle global. TikZ has some internal commands that may allow one to avoid this, and to just smuggle the macro outside the path. Specifically, @DavidCarlisle suggested in the chat to use pgfmath@smuggleone. However, my above attempts failed, i.e. if I uncomment



%smuggleoutone#1


the code produces errors.



QUESTION: Can one smuggle the macro outside the group without making it global?



"BONUS": Of course it would be great if there was an explanation what all the smuggle commands do.



"BONUUUUS": Conceivably these methods may be useful independently of TikZ, so if there is a way not to make them depend on TikZ being loaded, this would be great, but is certainly not a requirement.










share|improve this question
















I am seeking to find something that allows me to "broadcast" macros outside a group. Concrete examples include paths and scopes in tizpictures. Here is an M(N)WE.



documentclass[tikz,border=3.14mm]{standalone}
usetikzlibrary{calc}
makeatletter
letsmuggleoutonepgfmath@smuggleone
makeatother
begin{document}
begin{tikzpicture}[globalize/.code n args={2}{xdef#2{#1}},
localize/.code n args={2}{pgfmathsetmacro{#2}{#1}typeout{#2}
%smuggleoutone#1
}]
begin{scope}[local bounding box=extra]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
pgfextra{xdefmyangle{n1}};
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (extra.north) {using verb|pgfextra|};
%
begin{scope}[local bounding box=globalize,xshift=3cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[globalize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (globalize.north) {using texttt{globalize}};
%
xdefmyangle{7}
begin{scope}[local bounding box=localize,xshift=6cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[localize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (localize.north) {attempt to smuggle};
%
end{tikzpicture}
end{document}


enter image description here



The two options on the left do partly what I am seeking to do, namely broadcast the macro myangle outside the path. However, they do it at the expense of making myangle global. TikZ has some internal commands that may allow one to avoid this, and to just smuggle the macro outside the path. Specifically, @DavidCarlisle suggested in the chat to use pgfmath@smuggleone. However, my above attempts failed, i.e. if I uncomment



%smuggleoutone#1


the code produces errors.



QUESTION: Can one smuggle the macro outside the group without making it global?



"BONUS": Of course it would be great if there was an explanation what all the smuggle commands do.



"BONUUUUS": Conceivably these methods may be useful independently of TikZ, so if there is a way not to make them depend on TikZ being loaded, this would be great, but is certainly not a requirement.







tikz-pgf tex-core






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 4 hours ago







marmot

















asked 6 hours ago









marmotmarmot

92.8k4109203




92.8k4109203













  • @Circumscribe Good idea, let's clean up. (I wait till I get a sign from David before I accept your nice answer.)

    – marmot
    1 hour ago











  • Of course, that's fair. He'll know a lot more about this than I do. And he'll probably have a nice solution that avoids all global assignments and instead implements a loop inserting however many aftergroups are necessary :D.

    – Circumscribe
    1 hour ago



















  • @Circumscribe Good idea, let's clean up. (I wait till I get a sign from David before I accept your nice answer.)

    – marmot
    1 hour ago











  • Of course, that's fair. He'll know a lot more about this than I do. And he'll probably have a nice solution that avoids all global assignments and instead implements a loop inserting however many aftergroups are necessary :D.

    – Circumscribe
    1 hour ago

















@Circumscribe Good idea, let's clean up. (I wait till I get a sign from David before I accept your nice answer.)

– marmot
1 hour ago





@Circumscribe Good idea, let's clean up. (I wait till I get a sign from David before I accept your nice answer.)

– marmot
1 hour ago













Of course, that's fair. He'll know a lot more about this than I do. And he'll probably have a nice solution that avoids all global assignments and instead implements a loop inserting however many aftergroups are necessary :D.

– Circumscribe
1 hour ago





Of course, that's fair. He'll know a lot more about this than I do. And he'll probably have a nice solution that avoids all global assignments and instead implements a loop inserting however many aftergroups are necessary :D.

– Circumscribe
1 hour ago










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















5














You can "smuggle" definitions out of their group with the TeX primitive aftergroup. I'll first explain what aftergroup does, then give one possible definition of smuggleoutone and finally mention why you might want to use AfterGroup (from etextools) instead.



About aftergroup:



It is possible to insert a single token right after the end of the current group using aftergroup<token>.
You can only smuggle out one token at a time, so if you want to move out something consisting of multiple tokens (like a definition) you'll need to aftergroup each of these tokens separately. This includes things like braces ({}), so for instance



{aftergroupdefaftergroupabcaftergroup{aftergroup Aaftergroup Baftergroup Caftergroup}}


is equivalent to {}defabc{ABC}.



This is quite a hassle, so the following may be more practical:



{gdefsomethingunique{defabc{ABC}}aftergroupsomethingunique}


This works by globally assigning defabc{ABC} to somethingunique and inserting that after the end of the group.
If ABC is replaced by some macro, say ABC, that is only defined within the current group and that you want to be fully expanded then you'll want to use xdef instead:



{%
newcommand*ABC{ABC}%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpandabc{ABC}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


I've inserted noexpand in front of abc because we don't want abc to be expanded.
If you only want ABC to be expanded once you can instead use the slightly more complicated



{
newcommand*ABC{somethingthatshouldntbeexpanded}%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpandabc{unexpandedexpandafter{ABC}}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


The primitives noexpand, unexpanded and expandafter are all explained in this this answer.





Defining smuggleoutone:



To smuggle the definition of abc out of a group you can do what I did above with ABC replaced by abc itself.
This way abc is defined as itself (expanded once) immediately after the end of the group.



You could thus define your smuggleoutone command as follows:



newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


(You meant to use smuggleoutone#2 instead of smuggleoutone#1 by the way.)



There is one tiny problem with this definition though, and that is the fact that somethingunique is no longer unique if you use the same name every time.
It would thus be better to increment a counter every time this command is used and to store the thing you want to smuggle out in a macro whose names contains the value of this counter.
This is how the AfterGroup command, which I describe below, works (except that it also cleans up after itself).





Using AfterGroup instead:



The command AfterGroup is defined in the etextools package.
It acts like aftergroup, but it takes an argument that can consist of any number of tokens.
So, for instance, Aftergroup{defabc{ABC}} inserts defabc{ABC} after the current group without all of the aforementioned hassle.
There's also a starred version, Aftergroup*, that does the same thing but first expands its arguments fully.



An alternative definition would thus be:



usepackage{etextools}
newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
AfterGroup*{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
}


This definition shouldn't suffer from the aforementioned problem.







All of this applied to your MWE:



Here is your MWE with two changes: (1) I've redefined smuggleoutone and (2) I've uncommented smuggleoutone#1 and replaced #1 by #2 (I expect this was likely a typo).



documentclass[tikz,border=3.14mm]{standalone}
usetikzlibrary{calc}

usepackage{etextools}
newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
AfterGroup*{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
}
%% Alternative:
% newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
% xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
% aftergroupsomethingunique
% }

begin{document}
begin{tikzpicture}[globalize/.code n args={2}{xdef#2{#1}},
localize/.code n args={2}{pgfmathsetmacro{#2}{#1}typeout{#2}
smuggleoutone#2
}]
begin{scope}[local bounding box=extra]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
pgfextra{xdefmyangle{n1}};
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (extra.north) {using verb|pgfextra|};
%
begin{scope}[local bounding box=globalize,xshift=3cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[globalize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (globalize.north) {using texttt{globalize}};
%
xdefmyangle{7}
begin{scope}[local bounding box=localize,xshift=6cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[localize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (localize.north) {attempt to smuggle};
%
end{tikzpicture}
end{document}


output






share|improve this answer


























  • Thanks for the beautiful answer and the useful explanations!!!

    – marmot
    2 hours ago











  • You're welcome.

    – Circumscribe
    1 hour ago











  • I guess the only additional thing that might be interesting is whether you can jump also two or more levels that way. (But it is perfectly fine if you do not answer that.)

    – marmot
    1 hour ago











Your Answer








StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "85"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});

function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});


}
});














draft saved

draft discarded


















StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2ftex.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f470961%2fhow-to-properly-smuggle-with-or-even-without-tikz%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown

























1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes








1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









5














You can "smuggle" definitions out of their group with the TeX primitive aftergroup. I'll first explain what aftergroup does, then give one possible definition of smuggleoutone and finally mention why you might want to use AfterGroup (from etextools) instead.



About aftergroup:



It is possible to insert a single token right after the end of the current group using aftergroup<token>.
You can only smuggle out one token at a time, so if you want to move out something consisting of multiple tokens (like a definition) you'll need to aftergroup each of these tokens separately. This includes things like braces ({}), so for instance



{aftergroupdefaftergroupabcaftergroup{aftergroup Aaftergroup Baftergroup Caftergroup}}


is equivalent to {}defabc{ABC}.



This is quite a hassle, so the following may be more practical:



{gdefsomethingunique{defabc{ABC}}aftergroupsomethingunique}


This works by globally assigning defabc{ABC} to somethingunique and inserting that after the end of the group.
If ABC is replaced by some macro, say ABC, that is only defined within the current group and that you want to be fully expanded then you'll want to use xdef instead:



{%
newcommand*ABC{ABC}%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpandabc{ABC}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


I've inserted noexpand in front of abc because we don't want abc to be expanded.
If you only want ABC to be expanded once you can instead use the slightly more complicated



{
newcommand*ABC{somethingthatshouldntbeexpanded}%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpandabc{unexpandedexpandafter{ABC}}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


The primitives noexpand, unexpanded and expandafter are all explained in this this answer.





Defining smuggleoutone:



To smuggle the definition of abc out of a group you can do what I did above with ABC replaced by abc itself.
This way abc is defined as itself (expanded once) immediately after the end of the group.



You could thus define your smuggleoutone command as follows:



newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


(You meant to use smuggleoutone#2 instead of smuggleoutone#1 by the way.)



There is one tiny problem with this definition though, and that is the fact that somethingunique is no longer unique if you use the same name every time.
It would thus be better to increment a counter every time this command is used and to store the thing you want to smuggle out in a macro whose names contains the value of this counter.
This is how the AfterGroup command, which I describe below, works (except that it also cleans up after itself).





Using AfterGroup instead:



The command AfterGroup is defined in the etextools package.
It acts like aftergroup, but it takes an argument that can consist of any number of tokens.
So, for instance, Aftergroup{defabc{ABC}} inserts defabc{ABC} after the current group without all of the aforementioned hassle.
There's also a starred version, Aftergroup*, that does the same thing but first expands its arguments fully.



An alternative definition would thus be:



usepackage{etextools}
newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
AfterGroup*{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
}


This definition shouldn't suffer from the aforementioned problem.







All of this applied to your MWE:



Here is your MWE with two changes: (1) I've redefined smuggleoutone and (2) I've uncommented smuggleoutone#1 and replaced #1 by #2 (I expect this was likely a typo).



documentclass[tikz,border=3.14mm]{standalone}
usetikzlibrary{calc}

usepackage{etextools}
newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
AfterGroup*{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
}
%% Alternative:
% newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
% xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
% aftergroupsomethingunique
% }

begin{document}
begin{tikzpicture}[globalize/.code n args={2}{xdef#2{#1}},
localize/.code n args={2}{pgfmathsetmacro{#2}{#1}typeout{#2}
smuggleoutone#2
}]
begin{scope}[local bounding box=extra]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
pgfextra{xdefmyangle{n1}};
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (extra.north) {using verb|pgfextra|};
%
begin{scope}[local bounding box=globalize,xshift=3cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[globalize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (globalize.north) {using texttt{globalize}};
%
xdefmyangle{7}
begin{scope}[local bounding box=localize,xshift=6cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[localize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (localize.north) {attempt to smuggle};
%
end{tikzpicture}
end{document}


output






share|improve this answer


























  • Thanks for the beautiful answer and the useful explanations!!!

    – marmot
    2 hours ago











  • You're welcome.

    – Circumscribe
    1 hour ago











  • I guess the only additional thing that might be interesting is whether you can jump also two or more levels that way. (But it is perfectly fine if you do not answer that.)

    – marmot
    1 hour ago
















5














You can "smuggle" definitions out of their group with the TeX primitive aftergroup. I'll first explain what aftergroup does, then give one possible definition of smuggleoutone and finally mention why you might want to use AfterGroup (from etextools) instead.



About aftergroup:



It is possible to insert a single token right after the end of the current group using aftergroup<token>.
You can only smuggle out one token at a time, so if you want to move out something consisting of multiple tokens (like a definition) you'll need to aftergroup each of these tokens separately. This includes things like braces ({}), so for instance



{aftergroupdefaftergroupabcaftergroup{aftergroup Aaftergroup Baftergroup Caftergroup}}


is equivalent to {}defabc{ABC}.



This is quite a hassle, so the following may be more practical:



{gdefsomethingunique{defabc{ABC}}aftergroupsomethingunique}


This works by globally assigning defabc{ABC} to somethingunique and inserting that after the end of the group.
If ABC is replaced by some macro, say ABC, that is only defined within the current group and that you want to be fully expanded then you'll want to use xdef instead:



{%
newcommand*ABC{ABC}%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpandabc{ABC}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


I've inserted noexpand in front of abc because we don't want abc to be expanded.
If you only want ABC to be expanded once you can instead use the slightly more complicated



{
newcommand*ABC{somethingthatshouldntbeexpanded}%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpandabc{unexpandedexpandafter{ABC}}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


The primitives noexpand, unexpanded and expandafter are all explained in this this answer.





Defining smuggleoutone:



To smuggle the definition of abc out of a group you can do what I did above with ABC replaced by abc itself.
This way abc is defined as itself (expanded once) immediately after the end of the group.



You could thus define your smuggleoutone command as follows:



newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


(You meant to use smuggleoutone#2 instead of smuggleoutone#1 by the way.)



There is one tiny problem with this definition though, and that is the fact that somethingunique is no longer unique if you use the same name every time.
It would thus be better to increment a counter every time this command is used and to store the thing you want to smuggle out in a macro whose names contains the value of this counter.
This is how the AfterGroup command, which I describe below, works (except that it also cleans up after itself).





Using AfterGroup instead:



The command AfterGroup is defined in the etextools package.
It acts like aftergroup, but it takes an argument that can consist of any number of tokens.
So, for instance, Aftergroup{defabc{ABC}} inserts defabc{ABC} after the current group without all of the aforementioned hassle.
There's also a starred version, Aftergroup*, that does the same thing but first expands its arguments fully.



An alternative definition would thus be:



usepackage{etextools}
newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
AfterGroup*{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
}


This definition shouldn't suffer from the aforementioned problem.







All of this applied to your MWE:



Here is your MWE with two changes: (1) I've redefined smuggleoutone and (2) I've uncommented smuggleoutone#1 and replaced #1 by #2 (I expect this was likely a typo).



documentclass[tikz,border=3.14mm]{standalone}
usetikzlibrary{calc}

usepackage{etextools}
newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
AfterGroup*{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
}
%% Alternative:
% newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
% xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
% aftergroupsomethingunique
% }

begin{document}
begin{tikzpicture}[globalize/.code n args={2}{xdef#2{#1}},
localize/.code n args={2}{pgfmathsetmacro{#2}{#1}typeout{#2}
smuggleoutone#2
}]
begin{scope}[local bounding box=extra]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
pgfextra{xdefmyangle{n1}};
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (extra.north) {using verb|pgfextra|};
%
begin{scope}[local bounding box=globalize,xshift=3cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[globalize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (globalize.north) {using texttt{globalize}};
%
xdefmyangle{7}
begin{scope}[local bounding box=localize,xshift=6cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[localize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (localize.north) {attempt to smuggle};
%
end{tikzpicture}
end{document}


output






share|improve this answer


























  • Thanks for the beautiful answer and the useful explanations!!!

    – marmot
    2 hours ago











  • You're welcome.

    – Circumscribe
    1 hour ago











  • I guess the only additional thing that might be interesting is whether you can jump also two or more levels that way. (But it is perfectly fine if you do not answer that.)

    – marmot
    1 hour ago














5












5








5







You can "smuggle" definitions out of their group with the TeX primitive aftergroup. I'll first explain what aftergroup does, then give one possible definition of smuggleoutone and finally mention why you might want to use AfterGroup (from etextools) instead.



About aftergroup:



It is possible to insert a single token right after the end of the current group using aftergroup<token>.
You can only smuggle out one token at a time, so if you want to move out something consisting of multiple tokens (like a definition) you'll need to aftergroup each of these tokens separately. This includes things like braces ({}), so for instance



{aftergroupdefaftergroupabcaftergroup{aftergroup Aaftergroup Baftergroup Caftergroup}}


is equivalent to {}defabc{ABC}.



This is quite a hassle, so the following may be more practical:



{gdefsomethingunique{defabc{ABC}}aftergroupsomethingunique}


This works by globally assigning defabc{ABC} to somethingunique and inserting that after the end of the group.
If ABC is replaced by some macro, say ABC, that is only defined within the current group and that you want to be fully expanded then you'll want to use xdef instead:



{%
newcommand*ABC{ABC}%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpandabc{ABC}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


I've inserted noexpand in front of abc because we don't want abc to be expanded.
If you only want ABC to be expanded once you can instead use the slightly more complicated



{
newcommand*ABC{somethingthatshouldntbeexpanded}%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpandabc{unexpandedexpandafter{ABC}}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


The primitives noexpand, unexpanded and expandafter are all explained in this this answer.





Defining smuggleoutone:



To smuggle the definition of abc out of a group you can do what I did above with ABC replaced by abc itself.
This way abc is defined as itself (expanded once) immediately after the end of the group.



You could thus define your smuggleoutone command as follows:



newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


(You meant to use smuggleoutone#2 instead of smuggleoutone#1 by the way.)



There is one tiny problem with this definition though, and that is the fact that somethingunique is no longer unique if you use the same name every time.
It would thus be better to increment a counter every time this command is used and to store the thing you want to smuggle out in a macro whose names contains the value of this counter.
This is how the AfterGroup command, which I describe below, works (except that it also cleans up after itself).





Using AfterGroup instead:



The command AfterGroup is defined in the etextools package.
It acts like aftergroup, but it takes an argument that can consist of any number of tokens.
So, for instance, Aftergroup{defabc{ABC}} inserts defabc{ABC} after the current group without all of the aforementioned hassle.
There's also a starred version, Aftergroup*, that does the same thing but first expands its arguments fully.



An alternative definition would thus be:



usepackage{etextools}
newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
AfterGroup*{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
}


This definition shouldn't suffer from the aforementioned problem.







All of this applied to your MWE:



Here is your MWE with two changes: (1) I've redefined smuggleoutone and (2) I've uncommented smuggleoutone#1 and replaced #1 by #2 (I expect this was likely a typo).



documentclass[tikz,border=3.14mm]{standalone}
usetikzlibrary{calc}

usepackage{etextools}
newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
AfterGroup*{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
}
%% Alternative:
% newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
% xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
% aftergroupsomethingunique
% }

begin{document}
begin{tikzpicture}[globalize/.code n args={2}{xdef#2{#1}},
localize/.code n args={2}{pgfmathsetmacro{#2}{#1}typeout{#2}
smuggleoutone#2
}]
begin{scope}[local bounding box=extra]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
pgfextra{xdefmyangle{n1}};
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (extra.north) {using verb|pgfextra|};
%
begin{scope}[local bounding box=globalize,xshift=3cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[globalize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (globalize.north) {using texttt{globalize}};
%
xdefmyangle{7}
begin{scope}[local bounding box=localize,xshift=6cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[localize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (localize.north) {attempt to smuggle};
%
end{tikzpicture}
end{document}


output






share|improve this answer















You can "smuggle" definitions out of their group with the TeX primitive aftergroup. I'll first explain what aftergroup does, then give one possible definition of smuggleoutone and finally mention why you might want to use AfterGroup (from etextools) instead.



About aftergroup:



It is possible to insert a single token right after the end of the current group using aftergroup<token>.
You can only smuggle out one token at a time, so if you want to move out something consisting of multiple tokens (like a definition) you'll need to aftergroup each of these tokens separately. This includes things like braces ({}), so for instance



{aftergroupdefaftergroupabcaftergroup{aftergroup Aaftergroup Baftergroup Caftergroup}}


is equivalent to {}defabc{ABC}.



This is quite a hassle, so the following may be more practical:



{gdefsomethingunique{defabc{ABC}}aftergroupsomethingunique}


This works by globally assigning defabc{ABC} to somethingunique and inserting that after the end of the group.
If ABC is replaced by some macro, say ABC, that is only defined within the current group and that you want to be fully expanded then you'll want to use xdef instead:



{%
newcommand*ABC{ABC}%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpandabc{ABC}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


I've inserted noexpand in front of abc because we don't want abc to be expanded.
If you only want ABC to be expanded once you can instead use the slightly more complicated



{
newcommand*ABC{somethingthatshouldntbeexpanded}%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpandabc{unexpandedexpandafter{ABC}}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


The primitives noexpand, unexpanded and expandafter are all explained in this this answer.





Defining smuggleoutone:



To smuggle the definition of abc out of a group you can do what I did above with ABC replaced by abc itself.
This way abc is defined as itself (expanded once) immediately after the end of the group.



You could thus define your smuggleoutone command as follows:



newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
aftergroupsomethingunique
}


(You meant to use smuggleoutone#2 instead of smuggleoutone#1 by the way.)



There is one tiny problem with this definition though, and that is the fact that somethingunique is no longer unique if you use the same name every time.
It would thus be better to increment a counter every time this command is used and to store the thing you want to smuggle out in a macro whose names contains the value of this counter.
This is how the AfterGroup command, which I describe below, works (except that it also cleans up after itself).





Using AfterGroup instead:



The command AfterGroup is defined in the etextools package.
It acts like aftergroup, but it takes an argument that can consist of any number of tokens.
So, for instance, Aftergroup{defabc{ABC}} inserts defabc{ABC} after the current group without all of the aforementioned hassle.
There's also a starred version, Aftergroup*, that does the same thing but first expands its arguments fully.



An alternative definition would thus be:



usepackage{etextools}
newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
AfterGroup*{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
}


This definition shouldn't suffer from the aforementioned problem.







All of this applied to your MWE:



Here is your MWE with two changes: (1) I've redefined smuggleoutone and (2) I've uncommented smuggleoutone#1 and replaced #1 by #2 (I expect this was likely a typo).



documentclass[tikz,border=3.14mm]{standalone}
usetikzlibrary{calc}

usepackage{etextools}
newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
AfterGroup*{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
}
%% Alternative:
% newcommand*smuggleoutone[1]{%
% xdefsomethingunique{defnoexpand#1{unexpandedexpandafter{#1}}}%
% aftergroupsomethingunique
% }

begin{document}
begin{tikzpicture}[globalize/.code n args={2}{xdef#2{#1}},
localize/.code n args={2}{pgfmathsetmacro{#2}{#1}typeout{#2}
smuggleoutone#2
}]
begin{scope}[local bounding box=extra]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
pgfextra{xdefmyangle{n1}};
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (extra.north) {using verb|pgfextra|};
%
begin{scope}[local bounding box=globalize,xshift=3cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[globalize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (globalize.north) {using texttt{globalize}};
%
xdefmyangle{7}
begin{scope}[local bounding box=localize,xshift=6cm]
path let p1=($(2,1)-(0,0)$),n1={atan2(y1,x1)} in
[localize={n1}{myangle}];
node at (1,0) {myangle};
end{scope}
node[anchor=south] at (localize.north) {attempt to smuggle};
%
end{tikzpicture}
end{document}


output







share|improve this answer














share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited 1 hour ago

























answered 2 hours ago









CircumscribeCircumscribe

5,4811634




5,4811634













  • Thanks for the beautiful answer and the useful explanations!!!

    – marmot
    2 hours ago











  • You're welcome.

    – Circumscribe
    1 hour ago











  • I guess the only additional thing that might be interesting is whether you can jump also two or more levels that way. (But it is perfectly fine if you do not answer that.)

    – marmot
    1 hour ago



















  • Thanks for the beautiful answer and the useful explanations!!!

    – marmot
    2 hours ago











  • You're welcome.

    – Circumscribe
    1 hour ago











  • I guess the only additional thing that might be interesting is whether you can jump also two or more levels that way. (But it is perfectly fine if you do not answer that.)

    – marmot
    1 hour ago

















Thanks for the beautiful answer and the useful explanations!!!

– marmot
2 hours ago





Thanks for the beautiful answer and the useful explanations!!!

– marmot
2 hours ago













You're welcome.

– Circumscribe
1 hour ago





You're welcome.

– Circumscribe
1 hour ago













I guess the only additional thing that might be interesting is whether you can jump also two or more levels that way. (But it is perfectly fine if you do not answer that.)

– marmot
1 hour ago





I guess the only additional thing that might be interesting is whether you can jump also two or more levels that way. (But it is perfectly fine if you do not answer that.)

– marmot
1 hour ago


















draft saved

draft discarded




















































Thanks for contributing an answer to TeX - LaTeX Stack Exchange!


  • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

But avoid



  • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

  • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




draft saved


draft discarded














StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2ftex.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f470961%2fhow-to-properly-smuggle-with-or-even-without-tikz%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown





















































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown

































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown







Popular posts from this blog

Ponta tanko

Tantalo (mitologio)

Erzsébet Schaár